ETC (Exchange Traded Commodity)
Also: ETC, Exchange traded commodity, Commodity ETP
An ETC is an exchange-traded security that tracks the price of a single commodity. Legally it is a debt security and not a fund – unlike an ETF, the issuer is liable.
Enjoying what you see and read?
We pour our heart into keeping preciousmetalprices.com fast, clean and free — no paywalls, no clutter, just reliable facts and live prices. If it helps you, the nicest way to say thank you is to pass it on. Every share helps a fellow investor discover us and keeps the project going. 💛
Enjoying what you see and read?
We pour our heart into keeping preciousmetalprices.com fast, clean and free — no paywalls, no clutter, just reliable facts and live prices. If it helps you, the nicest way to say thank you is to pass it on. Every share helps a fellow investor discover us and keeps the project going. 💛
An ETC (Exchange Traded Commodity) is a security traded on an exchange that tracks the price of a single commodity – silver, copper or nickel for example. It is bought like a share, through any bank with exchange access.
For several metals on this site the ETC is the only form in which private investors can invest at all. Physical nickel or zinc is traded in quantities aimed at industry, carries the full standard VAT rate and would have to be stored somewhere.
Why not an ETF?
That is not a question of naming but a legal one. An ETF is a fund, and European funds are subject to the UCITS Directive. It requires a minimum spread of risk and forbids holding physical commodities directly. A product that tracks only a single metal therefore cannot be a UCITS ETF.
The ETC solves this by not being a fund at all but a debt security – a bond of the issuer whose repayment follows the metal price.
| ETF | ETC | |
|---|---|---|
| Legal form | fund | debt security |
| Your money is | ring-fenced assets | a claim against the issuer |
| If the issuer fails | protected | depends on the collateral |
| Single commodity | not possible | the normal case |
The difference that counts when it matters
With an ETF your money lies as ring-fenced assets at a depositary. If the fund company goes under, it remains yours – it is not part of the insolvency estate.
With an ETC that is not so. You are a creditor, and what you get back in the worst case depends on how the paper is collateralised. That is called issuer risk, and it is the most important difference between the two forms.
Three types of backing occur:
- Physically backed – for every unit real metal lies with a trustee. Xetra-Gold and Euwax Gold II work this way. The risk is thereby largely switched off.
- Fully collateralised – collateral is deposited whose value is checked daily and topped up.
- Uncollateralised – nothing but the creditworthiness of the issuer. Unusual for metals today, but such papers exist.
🔴 With industrial metals physical backing is the exception. Storing a tonne of nickel costs more than it earns in fees – these ETCs track the price through futures contracts and are collateralised accordingly, not backed.
What an ETC costs
The management fee is usually between 0.2 and 0.5 per cent a year and is taken continuously out of the product; you see no invoice, the unit value falls accordingly. On top of that comes the trading spread on the exchange when buying.
⚠️ How an ETC is taxed differs from country to country and has changed repeatedly in several of them. That belongs checked before buying and not taken from a glossary article.
Where the ETC reaches its limits
It tracks a price, it does not deliver metal. Anyone wanting bars in a safe cannot avoid the physical purchase – with everything that goes with it: premium, storage, and the dealer's spread when selling.
Conversely there are metals for which practically no ETCs exist. For rhodium, ruthenium and iridium there is no liquid futures market on which such a product could be built – there only the physical purchase from a specialist dealer remains.